Best Baby Registries Compared: Which One Is Right for You?
Choosing the best baby registry can feel overwhelming, with so many options offering different perks like completion discounts, free welcome boxes, and flexible return policies. Whether you want the widest selection, easy returns, or a universal registry, this guide will help you compare the top baby registry platforms so you can find the right fit for your growing family.
Top Baby Registries Compared
1. Amazon Baby Registry
Pros:
Largest selection of baby products.
15% completion discount for Prime members (10% for non-members).
Begins 60 days prior to the Arrival Date you entered in your Baby Registry and expires 90 days after the Arrival Date
Welcome Box with qualifying registry and minimum purchase.
One-year returns on most baby products.
Group gifting feature allows multiple people to contribute to a gift.
Cons:
Best benefits require Amazon Prime membership.
Some smaller brands and specialty products may not be available.
Create an Amazon Baby Registry here.
2. Target Baby Registry
Pros:
Shop in-store or online—great for testing strollers and other gear before adding them to your registry.
Welcome Box with qualified registry and purchase.
15% completion discount
Usable twice within 6 months with a Target Circle account.
Easy returns & exchanges for up to one year.
Cons:
In-store inventory varies by location.
No group gifting option.
Create a Target Baby Registry here.
3. Babylist Registry
Pros:
Universal registry lets you add items from any retailer.
Price comparison tool shows the best prices across multiple stores.
Cash fund options for diapers, meals, or even a babymoon.
Hello Baby Box available with a qualifying registry (requires $8.95 shipping).
Group gifting available on Babylist items only.
Cons:
15% completion discount only applies to Babylist’s own online store.
Discount valid for 60 days prior to due date and 90 days after due date (5 months total)
Requires multiple checkouts when purchasing from different stores.
Shipping costs vary by retailer.
Create a Babylist Registry here.
4. Walmart Baby Registry
Pros:
Shop in-store or online—ideal for testing strollers and car seats before adding them.
Baby Welcome Box with a qualifying registry and purchase.
Easy in-store returns & exchanges for one year.
Cons:
No group gifting feature.
Completion discount is not guaranteed—only available through occasional promotions.
Create a Walmart Baby Registry here.
5. BuyBuy Baby Registry
(Relaunching Under New Ownership)
Pros:
Wide selection of baby gear and essentials.
15% completion discount, valid for one year (must have spent $100 on registry items to qualify).
Free standard shipping on orders over $49.
Easy one-year returns.
Cons:
No group gifting available.
Cannot add items from other stores—registry is limited to BuyBuy Baby.
No longer has physical stores.
Recent changes in ownership may affect benefits.
Create a BuyBuy Baby Registry here.
Which Baby Registry Is Right for You?
The best baby registry depends on your shopping habits, budget, and what benefits matter most.
Consider where you already shop for convenience.
Look at completion discounts to save money on remaining items.
Think about return policies in case you change your mind or get duplicates.
Check if they offer group gifting or cash funds for extra options.
Need flexibility? Creating a couple baby registries can help you maximize discounts and gift options.
Final Thoughts
Your baby registry should make preparing for your little one easier, not harder. By choosing the right registry (or a combination), you can save money, access exclusive perks, and get everything you need hassle-free.
Need help building the perfect baby registry? Let me take the stress out of the process! As a baby registry consultant, I help parents create custom registries tailored to their needs—without unnecessary purchases.
💬 Which baby registry did you choose and why? Share your experience in the comments!
Data as of: February 2025
